Last night, as part of the Karazhan Gold Team we once again rolled through Kara. We started by clearing straight past Moroes to the Opera, only to be rudely told we couldn't do the opera without first killing Moroes. We quickly went back, killed him the first time through and then one-shot the Crone all within 15 minutes because there wasn't any trash to clear on our way up.

After taking out the Crone, we continued on to the Curator who decided we would have to take two tries at him due to some bad luck, so we took him down on the second try, and again, no Tier 4 piece for a mage dropped. Now, I don't even need the Tier 4 gloves, but I'd just like to see them. I'd just like to see the Gloves of the Fallen Hero drop once. Or maybe the Helm of the Fallen Hero from Prince Malchezaar. But what I'd really like to see are the Pauldrons of the Fallen Hero from High King Maulgar, but no dice. I've seen probably ten or so Tier 4 tokens drop, and not one of them has said "mage."

So after the Curator didn't drop a mage set piece, we continued on, one-shot Aran, and then went back to clear the trash. We mopped up the Maiden (who once again decided I was not going to get to upgrade my shoes), and then destroyed Attumen. Another successful trip into Karazhan. On Friday, Prince Malchezaar falls again, along with Terestian Illhoof.

Speaking of the Maiden not dropping my boots, the Crone last night dropped the Ruby Slippers. Now, I've been waiting for the Boots of Foretelling from the Maiden for a long time, but looking at the slippers, I'm not quite sure which are better - though I would assume the boots since that's what all my research has told me.

Ruby Slippers
134 Armor
+33 Stamina
+29 Intellect
Durability 50 / 50
Requires Level 70
Equip: Improves spell hit rating by 16.
Equip: Increases damage and healing done by magical spells and effects by up to 35.

Boots of Foretelling
134 Armor
+27 Stamina
+23 Intellect
Red Socket
Yellow Socket
Socket Bonus: +3 Intellect
Durability 50 / 50
Requires Level 70
Equip: Improves spell critical strike rating by 19.
Equip: Increases damage and healing done by magical spells and effects by up to 26.

So here we have the slippers with more stamina and intellect, yet no sockets. They also have spell hit instead of spell crit and 9 more damage. But with the red and yellow sockets, you can put in a Runed Living Ruby for 9 damage and then a Great Dawnstone for 8 spell hit. However, if you're at the hit cap like I am, the spell hit on the slippers is somewhat useless. But at the same time, if I get spell hit there, I can replace gems that provided spell hit on other items with gems that provide damage or spell crit. My current boots don't have any spell hit on them, so the boots are a more logical upgrade, but the slippers would have been a nice stop-gap upgrade until the boots drop (I did win the roll, but passed them to a healer in our raid who needed the upgrade more than I).

So I guess while I thought initially the boots and slippers might be pretty close in usefulness, upon further examination, the boots are clearly the correct way to go. My current boots:

107 Armor
+24 Stamina
+18 Intellect
Red Socket (ghetto +7 damage)
Yellow Socket (ghetto +3 crit, +4 damage)
Socket Bonus: +3 Intellect
Durability: 40 / 40
Requires Level 70
Equip: Improves spell critical strike rating by 17
Equip: Increases damage and healing done by magical spells and effects by up to 20.

24 STA, 21 INT, 20 CRIT, 31 DMG (Sigil-Laced Bots)
33 STA, 29 INT, 16 HIT, 35 DMG (Ruby Slippers)
27 STA, 26 INT, 27 CRIT, 35 DMG (Boots of Foretelling)

When presented like that, still a pretty close call and I could have gotten by for a long time with the Ruby Slippers I think. They also function as a hearthstone, freeing up a slot in my bags (I almost never use my hearthstone anyways). It's set to Gadgetzan so I can hearth or port to any corner of both continents. But like I said, passed on the slippers. Hopefully the boots will drop soon.