Finally!

Yesterday, I finally got the quest to go fish up a crocolisk in Stormwind. Upon returning to the cranky Old Man Barlo, he gave me the standard bag of fishing treasures, but this time, he finally decided I was ready to watch over my very own little crocolisk in a bucket: Toothy's Bucket!

I now have 66 pets and have moved up to #34 on the list of pet collectors. Here's my new updated list.